DURHAM: Attorney: Police 'illegally' recording interrogations - WSLS 10 NBC in Roanoke/Lynchburg Va

Attorney: Durham Police 'illegally' recording suspect interrogations

Posted: Updated:
Attorney Alex Charns said the Durham Police Department illegally records suspects during interrogations. Attorney Alex Charns said the Durham Police Department illegally records suspects during interrogations.
DURHAM, N.C. -

An attorney involved in several cases against the Durham Police Department is now trying to prove a trend with the agency that he compares to the NSA.

Attorney Alex Charns said the department is illegally recording suspects, pointing to one of his own clients, Willie Hayes, as an example.

Hayes was charged in July 2012 with felony conspiracy burglary, robbery and assault with a dangerous weapon and kidnapping. Charns said officers were recording his client's interrogation when they allowed Hayes' mother in the room.

"When the detective steps out, the recording doesn't stop, it continues as the angry mom is yelling at the son who is crying. That is recorded," Charns said. "It's put into a report, it's released to the [district attorney] and it's used to prosecute him."

Charns said Hayes, who was a juvenile at the time, did not sign a consent form to be recorded and officers essentially tricked him into incriminating himself.

"They tricked the mom and the son," Charns said. "It was a coercive interrogation. It's unconstitutional."

According the Durham Police Department policy, officers are required to record an interrogation in its entirety when the investigation is of a juvenile. However Charns argues that the unauthorized recording violates federal wiretap and state microphone surveillance laws.

"When the officers walked out of the room, our contention is at that point, it's an illegal electronic surveillance, an illegal microphone surveillance," Charns said.

Charns said he believes the recording is part of a larger problem.

"Look at what the NSA does. The Durham Police Department, in the past, had their little, mini NSA operation going," Charns said. "Is anyone watching? Does anyone care this is going on? Because it's wrong and it should stop."

To validate his claims, Charns filed a subpoena for police recordings of other interrogations dating back to 2010, however the police attorney wanted that request dismissed.

"I think it is unduly burdensome to begin with," police attorney Toni Smith said. "That would require the police department to go through thousands of criminal cases to determine where there are recordings and where there are not. Secondly, I think it's unreasonable because, again, it's not related to this particular defendant."

Ultimately a judge allowed the subpoena for recordings going back just one year prior to Hayes' interrogation.

We looked over the department's policy -- which requires a recording to continue until the person being interviewed has permanently left the room.

Police could not comment specifically on this case because it's still in the courts.

A trial date has not yet been set.

Charns is also the attorney for the family of Jesus Huerta, who died from a gunshot wound to the head in November while handcuffed in the back of a Durham Police cruiser.

Justin Quesinberry

Justin is a reporter for WNCN and a North Carolina native. He has spent the better part of the last decade covering the news in central North Carolina.  More>>

  • Accident causing lane closures on Interstate 81-North

    UPDATE: Interstate 81 lane reopens after Botetourt Crash

    UPDATE: Interstate 81 lane reopens after Botetourt Crash

    Friday, July 25 2014 8:49 AM EDT2014-07-25 12:49:42 GMT
    Two lanes are still closed but traffic is now passing on the right shoulder.
    Two lanes are still closed but traffic is now passing on the right shoulder.
  • UPDATE: Crash on Interstate 81 in Montgomery Co.

    UPDATE: Crash on Interstate 81 in Montgomery Co.

    Friday, July 25 2014 9:09 AM EDT2014-07-25 13:09:04 GMT
    All lanes on I-81 southbound are closed due to a tractor trailer crash near mile marker 120
    All lanes on I-81 southbound are closed due to a tractor trailer crash near mile marker 120
  • Floydfest attracts people from all walks of life

    Floydfest attracts people from all walks of life

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 11:26 PM EDT2014-07-24 03:26:58 GMT
    FloydFest 13 kicked off on Wednesday. Thousands of people from different walks of life will attend various events. Some come to the music festival to escape the monotony of everyday living."
    FloydFest 13 kicked off on Wednesday. Thousands of people from different walks of life will attend various events. Some come to the music festival to escape the monotony of everyday living."

  • Trending StoriesTrending StoriesMore>>

  • Woman impales herself on cemetery fence; says she was running from attacker

    Woman impales herself on cemetery fence; says she was running from attacker

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 2:53 PM EDT2014-07-23 18:53:18 GMT
    A woman claims she was running from an attacker and tried to jump a five foot fence when she became impaled. Firefighters had to use power saws and a grinding saw to cut her free, all while she was conscious. After 30 minutes she was transported to an area hospital for surgery to remove the spike sticking out of her thigh. It happened at Vine Cemetery in Hazleton. She said the nearest gate was locked. Witnesses backed...
    A woman claims she was running from an attacker and tried to jump a five foot fence when she became impaled. Firefighters had to use power saws and a grinding saw to cut her free, all while she was conscious. After 30 minutes she was transported to an area hospital for surgery to remove the spike sticking out of her thigh. It happened at Vine Cemetery in Hazleton. She said the nearest gate was locked. Witnesses backed...
  • 2 charged with first-degree murder in beating death of UNC professor, cancer researcher

    2 charged with first-degree murder in beating death of UNC professor, cancer researcher

    Friday, July 25 2014 9:00 AM EDT2014-07-25 13:00:14 GMT
    A UNC research professor was robbed and beaten to death Wednesday afternoon on University Drive in Chapel Hill, police said.
    A UNC research professor was robbed and beaten to death Wednesday afternoon on University Drive in Chapel Hill, police said.
  • Largest companies by revenue in each state

    Largest companies by revenue in each state

    Thursday, July 10 2014 8:01 PM EDT2014-07-11 00:01:10 GMT
    Broadview Networks recently decided to find out the biggest -- by revenue -- company in each state in the US.The company used the Fortune 500 list to start with, but needed data by state, so it turned to Hoover's.With data from that company, they were able to search through each state's list of companies and then find the largest -- by revenue.Just flip through the list above and see who is the biggest in each state, what town they are based and their revenue.
    Broadview Networks recently decided to find out the biggest -- by revenue -- company in each state in the US.The company used the Fortune 500 list to start with, but needed data by state, so it turned to Hoover's.With data from that company, they were able to search through each state's list of companies and then find the largest -- by revenue.Just flip through the list above and see who is the biggest in each state, what town they are based and their revenue.
Powered by WorldNow

WSLS 10, P.O. Box 10
Roanoke, VA 24022-0010

Telephone: 540.981.9110
Fax: 540.343.3157
Email: news@wsls.com

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.