Skip to main content

Jeff McNeil's home run and sparkling defensive play carry Mets past Yankees in Subway Series

1 / 5

Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.

New York Mets' Jeff McNeil (1) celebrates with Brett Baty (7) after scoring on his two-run home run during the seventh inning of a baseball game against the New York Yankees, Friday, July 4, 2025, in New York. (AP Photo/Angelina Katsanis)

NEW YORK – Jeff McNeil, arms clasped behind his back, tossed his bat and shouted toward the New York Mets dugout, starting up the first base line as his go-ahead, two-run homer in the seventh inning off Luke Weaver sailed into the second deck at Citi Field.

Twenty-five minutes later, the second baseman sprinted a half-dozen steps to his left, sprawled onto the outfield grass and with an outstretched glove angled toward the right-field corner snagged DJ LeMahieu's one-hopper. McNeil popped to his feet and threw to first for the second out of the ninth.

Recommended Videos



ā€œThe homer was sick,ā€ McNeil said after the Mets overcame a pair of two-run deficits to beat the New York Yankees 6-5 on Friday in the opener of this season's second Subway Series. ā€œI love hitting homers. I don’t hit that many. But at the same time, because I hit the home run, I think that play was a little bit bigger.ā€

In a thrilling back-and-forth struggle on a sunny Fourth of July that included seven home runs, the Yankees wasted 2-0 and 5-3 leads and the Mets squandered a 3-2 advantage. The Mets won their third straight game after losing 14 of 17, while the Yankees lost their fifth in a row.

Both teams were in first place when their series in the Bronx began on May 16. The Mets were a big league-best 45-24 on June 12 and the Yankees 42-25, and then both plunged like skydivers. The Mets are 6-14 since and the Yankees 6-15.

With 13 pitchers on the injured list, the Mets gave 28-year-old right-hander Justin Hagenman his first major league start. Jasson DomĆ­nguez went deep leading off, ending a 32-game homerless streak, and Aaron Judge followed with his 32nd home run. Hagenman retired his next nine batters.

ā€œAll of New York here basically watching the game,ā€ he marveled.

DomĆ­nguez misplayed Brandon Nimmo’s leadoff drive into a double starting the bottom half and Juan Soto followed with a two-run homer off Marcus Stroman.

ā€œHe’s kind of getting the momentum right back,ā€ Mets manager Carlos Mendoza said about Soto's shot. ā€œThat was kind of like a setting-the-tone moment. OK, they punch, we’re going to punch back. ... It's game on.ā€

Soto went 1 for 10 with no extra-base hits in his Yankee Stadium return. He had three hits in this one, doubling in the third and scoring when Pete Alonso singled on a 108.3 mph scorching grounder off the glove of shortstop Anthony Volpe.

Cody Bellinger's homer tied the score in the fourth and DomĆ­nguez hit a two-run homer for a 5-3 lead in the fifth against Austin Warren. Brett Baty's sixth-inning homer against Ian Hamilton cut the margin to one.

Weaver relieved with two outs in the seventh and walked Alonso. McNeil worked the count full and figured he'd get a pitch at the bottom of the strike zone. He hit a no-doubt drive on the fourth changeup of the at-bat, his ninth home run this season.

Now 33 and a two-time All-Star, McNeil has been with the Mets organization since they drafted him a dozen years ago.

ā€œHe’s a gamer, man, and he’s always ready to go,ā€ Mendoza said. ā€œHe’s a pretty important player for this roster.ā€

Weaver has allowed homers in three straight appearances. After compiling a 1.05 ERA in his first 24 games, he has a 13.50 ERA in seven outings since returning from a strained left hamstring.

ā€œI said I’ve been feeling good. That just might be a lie now. I don’t know. It’s hard to make sense of what’s going on,ā€ Weaver said. ā€œAt this point I’ve got two options. I can sulk and feel bad for myself or I can foundationally grind and find a way to just be flat-out better.ā€

Reed Garrett, who had a 15.00 ERA in his previous eight appearances, worked the eighth for a depleted Mets bullpen, getting three outs around a single. Garrett tried to avoid Mendoza when he got back to the dugout.

ā€œI was trying to walk away so he couldn’t take me out of the game,ā€ Garrett said.

With closer Edwin DĆ­az unavailable after pitching the previous two days, Mendoza let Garrett work the ninth.

Trent Grisham, pinch hitting for the slumping Volpe, flied out. LeMahieu followed with his looping one-hopper toward the hole that seemed destined to be a hit.

ā€œHe comes out of nowhere and just dives for the ball and really, really got me shocked,ā€ said Soto, who was charging in from right field.

ā€œIt's by you, you've got to just throw your glove at it and try to kind of scoop it," McNeil said. ā€œI knew it was a big play because I knew Judge was up fourth that inning and we don’t want him coming to the plate.ā€

Five pitches later, DomĆ­nguez hit a routine grounder to McNeil. Garrett screamed and pumped a fist.

ā€œI think we’ve shown a lot over the last month of just who we are as a team,ā€ he said. ā€œI think if you back us into a corner, we’re going to fight our way out of it.ā€

___

AP MLB: https://apnews.com/hub/mlb


Recommended Videos